• Welcome to the Angry Joe Show Army!

    Join our community of gamers passionate about our community and our hobby! Whether it's playing, discussing, or watching games, regardless of platform, genre, or location, we have a place for you, always!

  • PS4 Forum

    The AJSA Playstation 4 Division: Game Nights and More!

    The AJSA is on Playstation 4! Join us for weekly Game Nights with a selection of the best games the PS4 has to offer!

  • XBO Forum

    The AJSA Xbox One Division: We Got You Covered!

    The AJSA Xbox One Division is ready to connect with you on XBox Live with a ton of events for the best Xbox games!

  • News Archive

    The Best News from the Best Sites, Every Week.

    The AJSA News Collection Team is hard at work condensing a week's worth of news into one giant-sze digest for you to chew on and discuss! Links to source articles are always provided!

  • More Info

    The AJSA Expeditionary Force: Deploying to Play the Best PC Games!

    The elite vanguard of the AJSA, the Expeditionary Force (EF) chooses a new PC game every week! Join us for weekly events and help decide if the game has a future in the AJSA.

  • The Team

    Streaming Now: The AJSA Stream Team

    Joe can't stream every game, but our talented AJSA Stream Team covers a wide variety of games and personalities! Check them out, and show them some AJSA Love!

  • The Tube

    The AJSA Community YouTube Channel

    Featuring news, gameplay clips, and more from the community! The Community is a chance to showcase the best moments in AJSA Gaming!

DaJohnnyU

Assassin's Creed 4 Black Flag is a HUGE disappointment (Spoilers included)

4 posts in this topic

AC4 Campaign is a HUGE disappointment and I m gonna try and explain why in FULL detail below this. Please READ this before you judge me for Posting this all over other dishonest reviews that gave this game a near perfect rating. 

 

I just want to say before all this, I love this franchise, if I don't I wouldn't put all the effort here, all I wanted to do is to share these with people BEFORE they make their purchase cos money don't grow on trees and there are ton of other games that deserves it than this game at full retail price. No but instead everyday I wake up I get insulting comments and emails by fanbois who refuse to admit the game's problems and actively attack others for having a different perspective than themselves. I never intended to offend anyone with my posts on other reviews. I tried my best to be civilize  and polite and provided well constructed counter arguments.  So if you have any questions or if you like to defend the game, please comment below and I ll try my best to answer them. 

 

Melee combat is worst than AC3. Bare bone stealth mechanics(apparently bushes and tall grass are your best allies) with broken AI which will fail your mission countless times or engage you into an open battle. 
Ship battles lacks power and good sound assets unlike AC3 where cannons felt powerful. But here enemy ships are EXTREMELY cannon ball spongy.
Story lacks real emotional impacts with these card board characters that are lack of emotions and personalities. I can go into detail on the poorly scripted story but this is considered as spoilers.
Very Limited mission variety for both side quests and main quests. less craftable items(you can only craft health upgrade, 3 gun holsters and pouches for darts and bullets, and you can just buy materials at a weapon shop .....Seriously?!!!) and less weapon choices(you have 3 weapons and 3 gadgets only, and you get 1 of them gadgets during the middle of the story and 1 at almost the end). Here is everything I have encountered within the game, and unlike those so called "reviews" on YouTube, I would actually like to share these problems with people, to help people distinguish what kind of game this is with its pros and cons. Rather than being influenced by those carefully crafted marketing materials
 

You can have your own opinion and I m not gonna judge you for that because I don't have the right to do that nor that I intent to. But I am gonna explain why I said what I said and the reasons behind it. Please understand I m not trying to have/start a fight,  I m simply sharing my opinions with people, to look out for other gamers, to inform rather than influence, and regardless of what I said it shouldn't change you from enjoying the game if you love the game strongly(I m actually quite envied of you for it)(ps. I would love to make a video about all of this, but I m not intellectually and creatively capable of doing such thing yet, so I m sorry about these long comments and my lack of skills in English since they are not my first language, I m really sorry but hopefully you can understand) 

 
Ok first, the reason why I did this on all other YouTube AC4 reviews is because I hate these reviews in the first place, they are awfully short, they usually don't share any problems of the game with the gamers and we are all in the dark but they don't because they get review copies before the release, and all they did was to cover/avoid/misdirect/ignore the bad with good stuffs and fancy words and witty comments just like a typical salesman. I can't trust these reviews because of these Which is why all reviews like this to me felt like just another commercial to sell me the game. I didn't say any pros because all these reviews said was pros. And Frankly I just hate the score system within the journalist industry, they have no reasons behind them and highly influential and misleading to gamers. I don't care what score The War Z or Ride to hell retribution or Day one Garry's incident got, I care what people said about them and exposed what's wrong with them. So I amongst many others avoided them. I m not comparing AC4 to these games, please read carefully. 

 

OK the problems with the game, first the story and it's characters(spoilers included from now on) 

 

Edward-- I do enjoyed the flashbacks of Caroline(his wife), to me it showed Edward just another man wanted to provide for his family, and I do emphasize with this. But there were only 3 or 4 of these little flashbacks and there are no memories of how they met each other and cared for each other therefore I can't feel the love he has for her. Instead he spend most of his time doing what exactly? He was funny at the start of the game, but as the game moves on, he gets moodier and moodier after each section. And the fact that Caroline was never mentioned outside of these flashbacks then at the end Edward gets a letter and a daughter for no reason. is she sick? is she dead? who knows ? I don't.(She died, they literally said "she died" during the end credit)

"Friends" and Villains- these are suppose the people you care about in an assassin's creed game yet by the end of the game, I can't remember any of them except Mary,Ann, Blackbeard(Thatch), your second in command(the slaver guy) and Robert(The asshole sage who played Edward again and again). all others lacks emotions, traits, and personalities. And all Edward did was do 1 or 2 missions for them or just kill them or they disappeared forever or they dies in a cutscene, there aren't any interactions with your "friends" outside of the missions and you can't learn any of them of what they are. Plus the fact all your crews look alike either a black guy face or a white guy with mustache or without, they don't do nothing in combat other than interrupt your combos, get in the way, get killed or very rarely kill one enemy out of 15 or 20. They suck at their job, and I didn't care much for them too. 

During the story one of your "friend" betrayed you and stole your ship and left you stranded on an island with all your weapon. And what happened next?  instead of making an effort get it back you get your ship back instantly after a frigging cutscene, and your "friend" alive and imprison by you. Wow just incredible.  
The story keeps jumps from time to time and felt forced pushed abruptly and rushed, I advanced one month because blackbeard said to meet him after a month, what did he do in that one month? I have no idea. 

The ship battle are unsatisfying with poor sound assets. Ship battles in AC3 was the best thing not just in that game, but its one of the best game mechanics in the history. loading cannons takes time and firing them takes precision, enemy ships didn't have any healthbars, and that's OK because you can tell how badly damaged they are just by looking at them. Every time you fire you can almost hear each cannon balls being fired and you shouted "FIIIIIIIIIIIRRRREE"at the same time  they were loud and powerful and they got you PUMPED, and you and you crew all cheered after a hit, it felt nothing but satisfaction and awesomeness.  
But AC4's ship lacks all of these wonderful features. poor sound quality for the cannons is just no match to AC3, you will spam cannons again and again rapidly but no real effect on the other ship other than it's healthbar goes down a sliver. Sure that's the progression of gameplay, but even with all the upgrades to my ship and I do mean all of them, it still took sooo long to take down a ship, even in the medium difficulty section of the map, since every battle is like that late game, it to me felt so repetitive and just hated it, so I just avoided all of it. Sure you can have your fun, but if a pirate game made me avoid sinking other ships, surely that's a design flaw and someone else felt it too? And people keeps saying its built from ground.

The Combat- You are right, the animation are all copied and pasted from AC3, but why I said it's worse, because of the enemies. There are 4 different reaction from enemies, one take 4-5 slashes straight unless interrupted and killed in a execution animation, one will deflect all melee attacks unless you break his defense, and then 4 slashes or 1 slash kill if you are behind them which is the best option to kill one enemy quickly, one will counter your attack as well as deflect, and you can't counter him only dodge him, and he keeps throw grenades at you, and one elite enemy only be hurt from counter, and deflect all attacks and break defense won't work on him, and he will shoot you from far. Pretty complex, but if you are surrounded with all of them, which will happen sometimes in the game, you will understand why things are worse here, and especially bad on enemy ships some times even getting attacked and interrupted by enemies that wasn't in the camera that and the fact your crew keeps interrupt you too. There are no lock on feature this time, so you will attack one enemy once then start attacking others. Sure you can shoot people to make the combat easier, you can quad wield guns, it's cool at the start, but you can soon realize, guns are loud, it draws all nearby enemies to you, and you can't reload them without running around like a chicken cos you will get hit and cancel your reload, and you can't reload after fire just one gun, you have to waste all other shots, so you can reload the gun one by one till you get all four. People say combat isn't the strength of this franchise, and I do agree, but this one just took me right out of the game, it wasn't a great experience for me. 

The Stealth- With broken AI, this one isn't much of joy for me either. Enemies detects you way to quick for you to notice them, and sometimes I can't even see him only I look carefully I saw a little head from a rooftop far away with most of his body covered by other terrain. how am I suppose to do things stealthy when I can't see all my enemies properly and they see me clearly. Sure there are now a tagging mechanic in the game, but I can't even see them clearly or I m too far away to tag them but they sees me just fine, jeez they clearly went to specsavers(UK optical company). And when I went from bush to bush, of course I got again noticed why? Because there are way to many enemies all over the place, that's the thing, they all notice you too quick and have better vision than you. And during a engaged battle, you can't hide from their eye sight and get in a cover easily, so it's like hot pursuit, or GTA5 police as a bunch of guards chase you all over the place. It almost seems the all problems with stealth caused by broken AI, which I do hope they patch it in the future, but are the AI in AC3 fixed now? I seriously doubt that. There are no ranged silent weapon unlike AC3, the bow was pretty fun. You now have a blow pipe, with sleep darts and berserk darts, but if you are in stealth, and the effect of darts wears off, you will immediately goes into alerted(yellow) mode when you are in a bush, maybe it was a bug, but it certainly happened to me more than once. And for the longest time, I didn't even know the berserk darts kills people after duration, so I use them a lot later in game if AI weren't so broken at that moment. But you can't replenish them effectively without the shop or to loot tribes men which only appears in 2 islands or chase and tackle the courier only happens in city, cos most enemies don't have darts on them, you can craft these darts with animal bones, but you can only craft out of mission, and only one at a time and there is a "fill all" button in the shop menu, but not in here which was just strange to me. 

Oh less weapons and gadgets means less way to approach enemies both in or out of combat. In an open world game, it's not about use axes or swords or lance, it's not about making them look different but performs exactly the same only in different skin, it's about making each and every type of weapon unique with its own benefit, so you can choose freely. 

 

The open world-  The world is huge but empty, many will argue that there are islands for you to explore, but most of the island looks the same and only give you either 1 chest with insignificant amount of money (lost treasure my ass) or one freaking fragment that doesn't give you any benefit at all even after you collected them all, cos you know achievements are important(!)  Underwater sections (8 of them) are good, but I m not here to butter up this game. 

 

Later in the story you get your own base(stolen rather than liberated very pirate like style) and you can build other houses as well as upgrade your own house with money. However, these houses you build other than weapon shop and harbormaster served no real purpose, as well as upgrading your house with no benefit at all. Great I just dumped 15000R to make a whore house that don't do jack shit. Hell there aren't any enemies on this island. 

 

Mission- the main mission brought back some of the most annoy features from the previous tittle, on land missions features tailing your targets to a designated location which will often run into broken AIs and failing your mission countless times, then eavesdrop on them which requires you to stay close with your target and don't run out of this circle as well as not being detected, why can't I get the information I need when I m tailing them but of course the game forces these mechanics on you. Sea missions usually involve you to sail to a location to find your target then kill it or defend it from other instantly spawned enemy ships.  There are 3 kind of side missions only, no more missions from other factions like in AC brotherhood. There are assassin contracts that give you a target to kill with no more innovation and reward you 1000R or do it stealthy with 500R bonus. There are naval missions which requires you to either go to a place to sink few ships or loot a certain amount of item.  Also there are 4 Templar hunt missions with each splits into 4 little objectives(I can't call these things missions like others pretended they are), they were extremely quick to do with no effort put in. And THAT'S FUCKING IT for the side missions, For those people said lots of varieties, I call BULLSHIT. 

 

Kenway's Fleet- this one was locked without the passcode though now they remove the passcode to make it available to everyone. After you boarded the enemy ship, you have a option to send this ship to your fleet. Kenway's fleet looks like a facebook game, with all the ships you got, you can send them out to trade, kinda like the old Assassin recruit missions but not at all useful. Why am I bothered to send a ship out to trade for 15 hours(real time) only to receive 2000R in return, and that's all this feature does, a waste of time, with no real rewards.

 

To me, the game felt like a pirate themed AC3 stand alone expansion. Why AC2 was great? Because it improved almost every aspects in AC1. And can I just mention this is the 6th(or 7th if you count the liberation on PS vita) game in this franchise, and AC4 is the first game that never changed anything single player wise, after the success of AC2, AC brotherhood kept everything as well as adding the new assassin recruitment system, and after that revelation added a base defense mini game, even though I wasn't a fan Revelation offered a very satisfying conclusive ending for Ezio's storyline. Then AC3 despite it's boring characters and boring storyline, it added ship battles(which I strongly believe it was way better than AC4 and one of the best game mechanics in history), innovative combat offered much more fluid melee even though it made the combat easier, but still ubisoft trying to change things for the first time, I mean hell even climbing buildings was faster back in AC3.  And now in AC4 even though it kept the ship battle, but the game striped away everything else that made the previous tittles interesting. They had to go with a different character and story because they had no choice, but everything else is copied and pasted over without any polish and some felt just don't fit well within like a clock with unmatched parts. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

interesting read but i would advise to change the white on black its hard to read :)

DaJohnnyU likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

im sure compared to the other assassins creeds its considered a disappointment and im not going to lie i didn't read your whole post, just up to the point were u said spoilers from their on cause i didn't finish the game and didnt want to read any spoilers but i think you are right in a lot of aspects cause their defiantly isn't really much emotion behind the story line peoples 

"spoiler"

like i just got past the part were Blackbeard died and i mean i was kind of surprised by it but it wasn't really sad you barley did anything with him to begin with lmao but what im gettin at is being my first assassins creed game i really love it. and after hearing its the worst i really want to play the others. 

 

p.s. are the others as long as this one? cause i feel like this story line is never ending lol which i like really cause i like having so much game-play

 

p.p.s. you right too about the combat system its really mostly just smashing the left click and the e button lmao (if your playin on pc) i mean their is some like tactic behind it but not to much. its funny cause i just beat the newest hitman and like when im running behind enemy im thinking their going to hear me since running in hitman makes people look for you. sorry that was a ramble lol. also are the other assassins creed games even playable on pc?

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

im sure compared to the other assassins creeds its considered a disappointment and im not going to lie i didn't read your whole post, just up to the point were u said spoilers from their on cause i didn't finish the game and didnt want to read any spoilers but i think you are right in a lot of aspects cause their defiantly isn't really much emotion behind the story line peoples 

"spoiler"

like i just got past the part were Blackbeard died and i mean i was kind of surprised by it but it wasn't really sad you barley did anything with him to begin with lmao but what im gettin at is being my first assassins creed game i really love it. and after hearing its the worst i really want to play the others. 

 

p.s. are the others as long as this one? cause i feel like this story line is never ending lol which i like really cause i like having so much game-play

 

p.p.s. you right too about the combat system its really mostly just smashing the left click and the e button lmao (if your playin on pc) i mean their is some like tactic behind it but not to much. its funny cause i just beat the newest hitman and like when im running behind enemy im thinking their going to hear me since running in hitman makes people look for you. sorry that was a ramble lol. also are the other assassins creed games even playable on pc?

oh yes, every Assassin's Creed game is on PC and most of them are dead cheap, let me give you a bit of background of these games and my recommendations.

 

Assassin's Creed 1 is the story's beginning, and it was a very interesting and fairly original concept as you (or the main character) are a just a regular bartender who is abducted and imprisoned by this organization and use the machine Animus to access his ancestor's memory with his DNA. He plays his ancestor Altair, and assassin of this secret order in the year roughly 1190.  The gameplay was fairly simplistic although they all became the franchise's basic framework, as in you assassinate people, you can counter any incoming attacks and you do the parkours, you climb buildings and you jump up and down and stuff, like I said all the framework of the franchise is here(no bouts i ll get to that later).  Length wise it wasn't too long of a game, and the game has no multiplayers so it wasn't great content-wise. But over all it was very intriguing game and very original.

 

Assassin's Creed 2 continues from where you left off and you go back to another one of your ancestor's memory. This time is the 15th century Italy, you play as Ezio Auditore, a very well constructed character with humors and wits. Story wise it was a LOT better than the first game. Just everything is more polished than the first game and the game at this date still considered by many the best game of the franchise but personally I believe the reason why it is considered as such is because the huge improvements it provided. I strongly recommend you check this one out and at this time it's dead cheap.  Length wise it was longer than the first one, and the game has multiplayer for the first time, and was very exciting for gamers, although now it's dead for sure.  But overall the game is very well regarded. 

 

Assassin's Creed Brotherhood you continue the story of Ezio, this time in Rome you are tasked to liberate the city. The new feature this game provided is after you liberate an area of the city you can recruit a citizen into the order (12 max) and you can use him/her during the combat or an assassination and level up the recruits into a badass assassin at the end(light RPG aspect). Even though the combat is still the same and very easy with its rewarding counter system, it's great fun to just stand aside and watch your recruits take down enemies in a blink of an eye. The game's multiplayer has been polished and I think there are still people playing even it's just a very tiny amount.  This is my favorite AC game and till this day I can still go back and play with recruits. Gameplay wise this time there are a lot more gadgets for you to use during your adventure, so you have more options to deal with enemies stealthly or loudly just overall great fun.

 

Assassin's Creed Revelation is the final chapter of the Ezio storyline, it is the only AC game I did not FINISH and just watched a letsplay for the rest of it. However I did play it and I can tell you the game added a new tower defense mini game,  you stop the enemies from going from one end to the other end, you place your army on the roof top and each kill gives you money to place more soldiers or road blocks or traps. Personally I felt it was a very awkward control wise, and I did not enjoy it but I m not gonna hold it against the game cos that is only my personal preference. Combat wise everything is still the same, counter every incoming attack for the quick kill. BUT the last 10 mins of the story is the best of this game I believe, I know a certain amount of people said to others to just play the game for ending because of how satisfying it is.  The ending was very conclusive and I did enjoy it but I can't recommend the whole game for it. 

 

Assassin's Creed 3 is considered by many the worst game of the franchise but I respectfully disagree.  This time it's the american revolution and you play as Conor an native american who I believe coming from Ezio he is very poorly calculated character as in he was not a man of words and very humorless.  Gameplay wise, it is the first time that the combat has been redesigned. Conor moves very swift and attacks rapidly, just the whole animation of movement has changed with climbing buildings and running. It was very exciting to see the changes but it doesn't change the fact the combat is still easy and counter spam fest. I did 100% this game and it was very buggy at release, ubisoft even apologized for it and released many huge patches to fix the game, it even changed some of the quest objectives to make it easier to complete. However Naval combat has been introduced in this game, and OMG was it awesome, seriously, if you don't feel like pick this game up just search for the naval combat in AC3 and compare to AC4, it was that good.  In the end, this game tried new things but failed mostly just because of its boring main character and buggy release

 

So here are my opinions on these AC games, as you can probably tell, I had some great fun with the previous titles, and I would recommend you finish your playthrough of AC4 and come back and read the rest, and if you think I wrote a honest post, chances are you will see the problems too.  But please don't let my post cloud your mind as you played AC4 as your first game, me I played every other titles, just the frustration and the disappointment is not something you can experience and hopefully never will. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now